Canadian Leader in Poly B Replacement

Plastic or Brass Fittings & Which are Better?

Urban Piping Plumber Character
Which are Better Plastic or Brass Fittings
Urban Piping Plumber Character

When choosing plastic or brass fittings to use for PEX piping, there are many varieties of tools and products available to use. In general, plumbing fittings come in a wide range of products, but before choosing, you have to consider the cost, quality, and the ease of installation. Researching is always advisable otherwise, you might end up with a serious headache. Some plumbers who make use of the wrong fittings for PEX piping end up having to perform costly repairs and end up doing unnecessary warranty work.

Understanding Plastic or Brass Fittings

The choices for PEX fittings are uncountable. Marisa Chandley, who was a senior marketing manager for a vanguard plumbing company, a company that majorly sells fittings and PEX pipe explained her view, focusing on the fact that fittings have an ASTM (American Society for Testing and Materials) standard and are generally marked by third-party agencies such as NSF (National Science Foundation) and ULC (Underwriters Laboratories of Canada).

Plastic fittings have been considered to be less durable. Some are also of the opinion that plastic fittings may be of smaller diameter than that of brass fittings thereby making it less effective.  The basic fact is that plastic fittings is better and effective, unlike the brass PEX fitting. Korea and China are the major importers of cheap brass fittings. Sometimes they are mistaken for high standard fittings. The major thing to use when differentiating an original product from a fake is the UL or NSF mark by the side. This mark is very necessary another side you might not know the difference.

Due to the problem earlier caused by polybutylene (PEX predecessors) plastic PEX fitting have been recommended. It is true that in areas where water is less acidic, brass fitting is better. But in areas where water is acidic or easily contaminated, plastic fittings are better. Hot soils effect brass fitting as they tend to corrode easily. When they corrode it starts wearing away, it can cause failure at any time.

There are periods when brass fittings are most ideal. An example is when you are being exposed to a chemical agent at the application; plastic doesn’t react very well. But if upon application of certain chemical agents, brass is better to be used.

The brass PEX fitting and the plastic PEX fittings have some advantages as well as disadvantages, and I’ll like to explain them in detail.

Advantages of Plastic or Brass Fittings

Brass is a tough fitting

When looking for a  tough fitting to use, brass is a good example. It has some good strength and can be very reliable for PEX fittings.

Installation procedure

The easiest to install is the brass PEX fitting. All you need is a tool that clamps the copper crimp ring down. If that is properly done, within a few minutes, you are done with your installation.

Disadvantages of Brass fittings


The brass PEX fittings if not carefully used can affect the performance of pipes. If the water coming out through the pipe is acidic, the brass PEX fitting can easily burst. Brass PEX fitting generally does not have good performance.

It is prone to leakage.

When the weather temperature is hotter than expected, the brass PEX fitting doesn’t have the strength to withstand the heat and this most times results to severe leakage. This leakage takes time to stop even when measures are taking.

Original products are scarce

This is the most annoying part of the brass PEX fitting. It is very hard to see an original product. Most of the products are made in China and Korea and they don’t take a long time to wear out. When they start leaking, looking for measures to stop the leakage will never give a satisfying result as they are not made to last long.

It can corrode

The brass fittings can corrode although this depends on the water condition. The better the water condition, the lesser then tend to wear away.

It is costly

A lot of individuals prefer the plastic PEX fitting because the brass PEX fitting has proven to be more costly than any other PEX fittings. The cost of brass PEX fittings is not cheap, and this has resulted in an individual’s refusing to make use of it.

The plastic PEX fittings is preferably used by professional plumbers. This day’s professional plumbers are buying three times more plastic than brass. The brass PEX fitting cost almost 5 times than that of the plastic PEX fittings. When purchasing a plastic PEX fittings, you have more confidence as manufacturers trust them more than the brass PEX fittings.

Read: Copper vs PEX Piping- Which is Better

Advantages of plastic fittings

They are designed for use.

Plastic fittings can be easily re-mountable and are designed for use and reuse. They can be easily removed, cleaned, serviced and reused again. It doesn’t break when removed. It is very strong and can be remounted as many times as possible. The products made are all performing good jobs with fewer complaints.  

They rarely crush pipes.

It is very hard to see a plastic fitting to torque and crush a pipe. It will preferably strip than crush a pipe. No matter the outburst of water both acidic and contaminated, the plastic PEX fitting will typically never crush the pipe.

Less leakage.

This is one of the best features of the plastic PEX fitting. It doesn’t easily leak. Unlike the brass PEX fitting that leaks easily,  you can make use of the plastic PEX fitting for 10 years and still be rest assured that there will be no leakage.

Water condition

In areas where water is very acidic plastic PEX fitting is the most ideal. Plastic fittings do not corrode or wear out due to terrible water condition. It is very effective and highly durable and can be used in houses that have a lower quality water system.

Disadvantages of the plastic fitting

Installation process.

The installation process of the plastic fitting is a little tougher. Unlike the brass fitting that can easily be installed, the process of installation of the plastic fitting requires some rigorous procedures.

The plastic fittings has been criticized by people who have not made use of it as they feel it is going to be as bad as the polybutylene. The polybutylene left with a bad reputation, and since then users have refused to make use of the plastic PEX fitting. The polybutylene is good and has high pressures, but once they get in touch with disinfectant, they easily burst and leak. They do not delay in damaging the water system.

The brass fitting is not as effective as the plastic PEX fitting. The fact that it easily corrodes makes it less useful to plumbers. Plumbers need to make use of good fittings when passing pipes in a house or a building. The brass doesn’t have any control over it fittings. If you are considering purchasing a good fitting for your pipe, it is better to make use of the plastic PEX fitting as it doesn’t easily corrode, it can be used for any water condition and doesn’t have fake products like the brass.

Continue Reading…

Follow Urban Piping on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram

This post is part of our commitment to transparent, helpful, and informative content for our readers and visitors. For more details on our editorial process and how we ensure accuracy and reliability, please visit our Editorial Process page.


Picture of Corey Hayes

Corey Hayes

Corey Hayes is a seasoned marketing professional with two decades of experience in small business marketing, dedicating 15 years of his illustrious career to elevating Urban Piping's brand. His expertise and visionary approach have been pivotal in shaping the company's market presence and success.

Picture of Corey Hayes

Corey Hayes

Corey Hayes is a seasoned marketing professional with two decades of experience in small business marketing, dedicating 15 years of his illustrious career to elevating Urban Piping's brand. His expertise and visionary approach have been pivotal in shaping the company's market presence and success.

Graham Drew

Graham Drew is the pioneering CEO of Urban Piping, a leader in Poly B pipe replacement with over 15 years of specialized home repiping experience. Renowned for completing more Poly B remediations than any other contractor, Graham has set industry standards, ensuring homeowners receive the utmost in safety and quality. His visionary approach and unwavering commitment have solidified Urban Piping’s reputation as the go-to expert for dependable and innovative piping solutions.

Table of Contents

Plumbing Topics

Urban Piping Ltd.

Poly B Replacement Case Studies

Poly B™ FAQ Videos

Poly B™ FAQ

55 Videos
Play Video

Learn More About Poly B Piping

Economical Poly B Piping Upgrade Strategies

The Legacy of Polybutylene Plumbing: Insights and Overviews

Evolution of Poly B Piping Materials Through Time

Urban Piping Solutions: Optimal Choices for Homeowners

Chronological Evolution of Poly B Pipe Installation Practices

Poly B Plumbing and Real Estate Value: Understanding the Connection

Secure Your Rights to Poly B Replacement Reimbursement

Sustainable Water Systems: Innovations in Eco-Friendly Plumbing

Comprehensive Guide to Poly B Replacement Expenses

How to Find the Ideal Poly B to PEX Conversion Service

Why PEX Outperforms Poly B in Modern Plumbing Systems

Choosing the Right Solution for Poly B Pipe Replacement

Poly B Piping: Understanding Its Origins and Applications

Exploring Urban Piping: The Comprehensive Poly B History Overview

Understanding Poly B Piping Health Risks

Why Replace Your Poly B Plumbing Now

Upgrade Poly B Fixtures: A Step-by-Step Guide

Financial Assistance for Poly B Replacement

Essential Plumber Role in Poly B Replacement

Poly B Pipes: Affecting Home Sales?

Poly B™ Impact on Real Estate Deals

What is Poly B Plumbing?

The Poly B Pipe Lawsuit: Origins, Impacts, and Solutions

Poly B Plumbing Issues: The Untold Truth You Should Know

Poly B Pipe Replacement Cost (2023)

10 Tips in Hiring for Water Line Replacement New Westminister

10 Tips in Hiring for Water Line Replacement Edmonton

Top 10 Reasons: Use Urban Piping for Poly B Replacement

Buying or Selling a Home With Polybutylene?

Why Replacing Polybutylene Is Time Sensitive

Effects of Chlorine on Polybutylene Piping

Poly B Pinhole Leak? Here’s What Happens

A Brief History on Poly B Lawsuits and Litigation

Poly B to PEX Piping & Making the Switch

Buying a House with Poly B Piping? Read This!

Difference Between Classes of PEX Piping

Color Coding Water Lines & Poly B Replacement

Poly B Drywall Repair & Best Practices

Finding the Right Poly B Contractor in Vancouver

What is Poly B (Polybutylene) Pipe?

Scroll to Top